Global Power Grids Show Minute‑Long Frequency Drops Linked to UPS Checks

Global Power Grids Show Minute‑Long Frequency Drops Linked to UPS Checks

Lead (5W1H) According to TechCrunch, power‑grid operators across Europe, the United States, Australia and Malaysia have been observing tiny, recurring drops in grid frequency every 60 seconds; the phenomenon was investigated by Dirk Witthaut of Germany’s Forschungszentrum Jülich, who traced the cause to synchronized state‑of‑charge checks performed by battery‑backed UPS systems and other internet‑connected devices.


The mystery of the minute‑long sags

For years, grid managers around the world have been puzzled by a subtle yet regular dip in electrical frequency that occurs once per minute, according to TechCrunch. The drops are small—measured in millihertz—but they appear simultaneously on transmission networks that span continents, raising concerns about potential grid instability.

The orderly operation of an electric grid depends on keeping the system frequency within a narrow band. As reported by TechCrunch, excessive oscillations can trigger blackouts or damage equipment, especially in hydropower turbines that are sensitive to ultra‑low‑frequency oscillations (UFLOs). Historically, hydropower plants have been associated with UFLOs because turbine vibrations can resonate at specific frequencies, much like a wine glass shattering under a sustained note.

Initial focus on hydropower

Witthaut’s team first examined hydropower as the most obvious source, building a computer model of a Scandinavian grid’s hydro‑plant control system. According to TechCrunch, the model demonstrated that under certain conditions a resonance could peak once per minute, but it could not explain the persistence of the phenomenon minute after minute. Mechanical resonances typically appear and fade, yet the observed frequency dips continued without interruption.

Realising that a perfectly regular interval implies a timing mechanism, the researchers hypothesized that a “clock” might be driving the effect.

On‑site measurements reveal the culprit

To test the clock hypothesis, the team installed more than 80 smart power‑quality meters around the Jülich campus, a site that includes medium‑ and low‑voltage distribution lines, transformers, solar panels, battery energy storage systems (BESS) that serve as uninterruptible power supplies (UPS), and a high‑performance computing cluster. As reported by TechCrunch, the meters recorded frequency, voltage, current and power every three seconds.

The data showed that the transformer feeding the BESS exhibited a peak in disturbance exactly every 60 seconds, mirroring the pattern seen on national grids. According to TechCrunch, many stationary batteries—ranging from data‑center UPS units to large grid‑scale storage installations—are programmed to check their state‑of‑charge once per minute. Because these devices are internet‑connected, their internal clocks are synchronized to a high degree of precision. Each individual check produces an imperceptible disturbance, but when thousands of devices act in unison, the aggregate effect becomes visible on the wider grid.

Evidence from national grid data

To confirm that UPS‑related checks were responsible for the global phenomenon, the researchers turned to frequency data supplied by grid operators. As reported by TechCrunch, Ireland provided a clear case study. By 2022, data centres accounted for 18 % of Ireland’s electricity consumption, and each centre is supported by a fleet of UPS units. Between 2016 and 2021, the minute‑by‑minute frequency dip on the Irish grid grew from 3 milli‑hertz (mHz) to 12 mHz, and more recent measurements have recorded drops exceeding 20 mHz.

Ireland’s 50 Hz system is designed to tolerate swings of ±200 mHz, although operators prefer to keep variations within ±100 mHz. According to TechCrunch, a 20 mHz deviation is modest in isolation, but when combined with other load‑induced fluctuations it could push the grid closer to instability thresholds.

Proposed mitigation

The researchers conclude that the issue is entirely preventable. As reported by TechCrunch, they recommend that manufacturers of UPS systems and grid‑scale batteries introduce randomization into the timing of state‑of‑charge checks, thereby breaking the perfect synchrony that amplifies the disturbance.

The study also examined Internet‑of‑Things (IoT) devices such as smart ovens and Raspberry Pi clusters, finding that similar periodic power fluctuations can arise from poorly timed firmware routines. According to TechCrunch, a simple software patch could stagger these operations, but less than 3 % of IoT devices run the latest firmware, leaving many vulnerable to the same problem.

Regulatory intervention may become necessary, but the authors note that regulators can only act within their jurisdiction, and the phenomenon’s global reach will require coordinated international standards.

Brief analysis (opinion)

The discovery underscores how seemingly innocuous digital controls can have physical ramifications on critical infrastructure. While the suggested randomization is a low‑cost fix, its adoption will depend on industry willingness to update legacy UPS firmware and on regulatory bodies to mandate such changes. If left unchecked, the cumulative effect of synchronized device checks could become a hidden stressor on power systems already challenged by renewable integration and rising demand.

Conclusion

According to TechCrunch, the minute‑long frequency drops that have haunted power grids worldwide are not the result of mysterious external forces but stem from the synchronized state‑of‑charge checks of battery‑backed UPS units and certain IoT devices. Introducing random timing into these checks offers a straightforward solution, though widespread implementation will require coordinated action across manufacturers, operators and regulators.

Source: TechCrunch

Frequently Asked Questions

What caused the regular one‑minute frequency drops on global power grids?

According to TechCrunch, the drops are caused by synchronized state‑of‑charge checks performed by battery‑backed UPS systems and some IoT devices, which create tiny disturbances that add up when many devices act at the same time.

Which country provided the clearest evidence linking UPS checks to grid frequency dips?

As reported by TechCrunch, Ireland’s grid data showed a clear increase in minute‑by‑minute frequency drops that correlated with the growth of data‑center UPS installations.

How can the issue be mitigated according to the researchers?

According to TechCrunch, manufacturers should add randomization to the timing of UPS and grid‑scale battery state‑of‑charge checks, and similar firmware updates could address the problem in IoT devices.

Source: TechCrunch — Read more

💻 Related Articles