Global Power Grids Show Minute‑Long Frequency Drops Linked to UPS Checks

Global Power Grids Show Minute‑Long Frequency Drops Linked to UPS Checks

Lead (5W1H) What: Minute‑long, ultra‑low‑frequency oscillations (UFLOs) appearing as tiny drops in grid frequency. Who: Investigated by Dirk Witthaut and his team at Germany’s Forschungszentrum Jülich, in collaboration with TenneT Germany and other grid operators. When: The phenomenon has been observed continuously for years and was documented in data spanning 2016‑2021, with recent spikes exceeding 20 mHz. Where: Detected on power grids across Europe, the United States, Australia, Malaysia and notably Ireland. Why: Synchronous state‑of‑charge checks performed by large numbers of battery‑backed UPS systems and grid‑scale storage devices. How: Each UPS queries its charge level once per minute; when thousands of devices act in unison, the cumulative load change creates a measurable frequency sag.


The mystery of recurring frequency sags

According to TechCrunch, grid operators worldwide have long been puzzled by a pattern in which the system frequency drops slightly every 60 seconds. The sags occur at the same instant on grids that span continents, raising concerns about potential instability. Maintaining frequency within a narrow band is essential for reliable electricity supply; large deviations can trigger blackouts or damage equipment such as hydropower turbines, which are especially sensitive to ultra‑low‑frequency oscillations (UFLOs).

Initial focus on hydropower

As reported by TechCrunch, the research team first examined hydropower plants because turbine vibrations can resonate at low frequencies, similar to a wine glass shattering under a sustained note. Using a computer model of a Scandinavian hydropower control system, the scientists reproduced a resonance that peaked once per minute. However, the model could not explain the persistence of the phenomenon—real‑world resonances typically appear and fade, whereas the observed grid sags continued unabated, minute after minute.

The breakthrough: a clock‑driven culprit

The breakthrough came when the team considered that any process occurring with perfect minute‑by‑minute regularity must be governed by a clock. To test this hypothesis, they deployed more than 80 smart power‑quality meters around the Jülich campus, which houses medium‑ and low‑voltage distribution lines, transformers, solar panels, battery energy storage systems (BESS), and both large and small uninterruptible power supplies (UPS). The meters recorded frequency, voltage, current and power every three seconds.

According to TechCrunch, the data revealed that the transformer feeding the campus‑wide BESS exhibited the same once‑per‑minute frequency peaks observed on national grids. The researchers identified that many stationary batteries—including UPS units for data centers and grid‑scale storage—perform a state‑of‑charge (SoC) check precisely every minute. Because these devices are internet‑connected, their internal clocks are tightly synchronized, causing them to draw a brief, simultaneous load from the grid at the same instant.

Evidence from the Irish grid

To confirm that UPS‑driven SoC checks were responsible for the global pattern, the researchers examined publicly available frequency data from Ireland, a country where data centers now account for a substantial share of electricity consumption. As reported by TechCrunch, data centers represented 18 % of Ireland’s grid load by 2022, each supported by fleets of UPS units. Between 2016 and 2021, the minute‑by‑minute frequency drop on the Irish grid grew from 3 milli‑Hertz (mHz) to 12 mHz, and more recent measurements have shown dips exceeding 20 mHz.

Ireland’s 50 Hz grid is engineered to tolerate frequency swings of plus or minus 200 mHz, though operators aim to keep fluctuations within 100 mHz. While a 20 mHz deviation is modest relative to those limits, the article notes that additional loads could compound the effect, potentially pushing the system closer to conditions that trigger protective shutdowns.

Broader implications for IoT and future grids

The study also investigated whether other internet‑connected devices might contribute similar disturbances. According to TechCrunch, tests on a smart oven and Raspberry Pi clusters detected periodic power fluctuations, suggesting that poorly timed firmware routines could have a comparable impact. The fix, the researchers argue, is a simple software patch that randomizes the timing of routine checks. However, a recent study cited in the article indicates that fewer than 3 % of IoT devices run the latest firmware, highlighting a gap in mitigation.

Recommended mitigation

Based on the findings, Witthaut’s team recommends that manufacturers of UPS systems and grid‑scale batteries incorporate randomization into the scheduling of SoC assessments. By staggering these checks, the collective load impact would be diffused, eliminating the synchronized frequency dip. The article warns that without such changes, the phenomenon could persist or even intensify as battery storage and UPS deployments expand globally.


Brief analysis (opinion) The discovery underscores how seemingly innocuous digital housekeeping tasks can ripple through physical infrastructure when billions of devices act in lockstep. While the suggested software patch is technically straightforward, achieving worldwide compliance will likely require coordinated standards and possible regulatory action. As the energy sector leans increasingly on battery storage and IoT‑enabled equipment, proactive design choices—such as built‑in timing jitter—will be essential to safeguard grid stability.


Conclusion

The coordinated minute‑long frequency drops that have haunted power grids across continents have been traced to synchronized state‑of‑charge checks performed by UPS units and large battery installations. By introducing randomness into these routine checks, the industry can eliminate the phenomenon and reduce the risk of cumulative grid stress. Ongoing vigilance will be needed as the proliferation of battery‑backed devices and IoT hardware continues to reshape electricity consumption patterns.

Source: TechCrunch

Frequently Asked Questions

What causes the one‑minute frequency drops on power grids?**

The drops are caused by many UPS systems and grid‑scale batteries performing a state‑of‑charge check exactly every minute, creating a synchronized load change that manifests as a tiny frequency sag. **Q: How large are the observed frequency drops?** A: In Ireland, the drops grew from 3 mHz in 2016 to 12 mHz in 2021, with recent instances exceeding 20 mHz. The grid can tolerate swings of ±200 mHz, though operators aim to keep them within 100 mHz. **Q: What solution do researchers propose?** A: They recommend adding randomization to the timing of UPS and battery state‑of‑charge checks, effectively spreading the load impact over time to prevent synchronized frequency dips.

Source: TechCrunch — Read more

💻 Related Articles